Comparison Console
Nitecore EDC23 vs Nitecore P17iX
EDC Flashlights comparison. Compare price, weight, specifications, materials, and real-world use case.
Command Brief
Recommended read
Nitecore EDC23 stands out as the cheapest option for retail price, with about a 41% gap from the closest alternative. Nitecore P17iX stands out as the highest output option for max lumens, with about a 100% gap from the closest alternative. Nitecore P17iX stands out as the longest runtime option for max runtime, with about a 156% gap from the closest alternative.
Decision Signals
What stands out
Nitecore EDC23 stands out as the cheapest option for retail price, with about a 41% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore P17iX stands out as the most expensive option for retail price, with about a 69% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore EDC23 stands out as the lowest output option for max lumens, with about a 50% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore P17iX stands out as the highest output option for max lumens, with about a 100% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore EDC23 stands out as the shortest runtime option for max runtime, with about a 61% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore P17iX stands out as the longest runtime option for max runtime, with about a 156% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore EDC23 stands out as the shortest option for length, with about a 27% gap from the closest alternative.
Nitecore P17iX stands out as the longest option for length, with about a 36% gap from the closest alternative.
Specification Profile
Relative dimensions at a glance
Each axis is normalized against the largest raw value among the products in this comparison. Farther outward means a larger value, not necessarily a better result. Axes with an unverified value are omitted.
Price & carry
Retail price
US$75Cheapest
US$126.44Most expensive
Weight
101 g (3.56 oz)
101 g (3.56 oz)
Length
102.8 mm (4.05 in)Shortest
140 mm (5.51 in)Longest
Output
Max lumens
2500 lmLowest output
5000 lmHighest output
Max candela
20720 cdLowest candela
27225 cdHighest candela
Beam distance
280 m (919 ft)Lowest
330 m (1083 ft)Highest
Max runtime
2340 minShortest runtime
6000 minLongest runtime
Power & durability
Battery type
Built-in 1500mAh Li-ion battery
1 x Nitecore 21700 i Series Li-ion rechargeable (NL2155HPi 5,500mAh)
Charging type
USB Type-C
USB-C 18W fast charging (QC/PD)
Rechargeable
Yes
Yes
IP rating
IP54
IP68 (2 meters submersible)
Impact resistance
2 m (7 ft)
2 m (7 ft)
Material
High strength stainless steel body with PVD titanium coating, carbon fiber reinforced polymer frame, aluminum heat dissipation plate
7075-T6 aluminum alloy with HA III military grade hard-anodized finish
Use case profile
Best for
Everyday carry (EDC)Tactical applicationsSecurity patrolLaw enforcementNight searchPersonal defenseEmergency lighting
Tactical and duty useLaw enforcementMilitarySearch and rescueOutdoor and professional lighting
Common praise
Compact and lightweight design suitable for pocket carryPowerful output of up to 2500 lumens with good beam throwOLED display showing brightness, battery, and runtimeFast USB-C charging with 1.5 hour full charge timeDedicated Turbo and Strobe switches for tactical useDual lock modes to prevent accidental activation
Exceptional brightness and beam throwVersatile beam pattern optionsRobust and durable constructionProgrammable buttons provide operational flexibilityLong battery runtime with fast USB-C charging
Common complaints
No true moonlight mode; lowest output is around 14-15 lumensOnly IP54 rated, not suitable for heavy water exposureBody finish prone to smudge and easy to markHeavier and denser due to stainless steel, less preferred by some usersMode interface complexity with strobe access sometimes accidental
Battery and accessories excluded from weight; actual carry weight higherComplexity of multiple modes may require learning
Dataset Expansion
Missing a brand?
Suggest an EDC brand for CarryCrew to research and add to the comparison database.
Community indexing queue online